• Current Reads

      Life after Life Jill McCorkle
      This Is Your Captain Speaking Jon Methven
      The Starboard Sea Amber Dermont
      Snark David Denby
      Bring Up the Bodies Hilary Mantel
  • Popular Tags

  • Recent Reflections

  • Categories

  • Moleskine’s All-Time Favorites

  • Echoes

    The HKIA brings Hong… on [788] Island and Peninsula 島與半…
    Adamos on The Master and Margarita:…
    sumithra MAE on D.H. Lawrence’s Why the…
    To Kill a Mockingbir… on [35] To Kill A Mockingbird…
    Deanna Friel on [841] The Price of Salt (Carol…
    Minnie on [367] The Rouge of the North 怨…
  • Reminiscences

  • Blog Stats

    • 1,087,596 hits
  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 1,709 other followers

[311] An Instance of the Fingerpost – Iain Pears

” Two men, it seems, can see the same event, yet both remember it falsely. How, he went on, will we ever reach certainty on anything, even when of good will? . . . But how can I tell which assertion to believe, and which to reject? ” [Part 4:1]

Nothing is ever as it seems in An Instance of the Fingerpost. In using four different (unreliable) narrators, Iain Pears weaves webs of deception and misapprehension, using omission and outright lies to confuse the truth. Each of the four accounts—a Venetian physician, a traitorous soldier’s son, a mathematician, and a historian—has distinct motive and reason that render the self-contained (and self-conscious) account less objective and misleading.

In 1663, England is wrecked with intrigue and civil strife. The king is nearly toppled from his throne. Thousands of dissenters are locked in the jail. Rumors of war across the North Sea are boiling. It’s a time when everyone is a fool, a liar, a murderer, a cheat, or a traitor. All men are subjects to be twisted to serve their ends. These secretive and frightening events form the theater set for the death of Dr. Robert Grove, an Oxford don found dead in his rooms at New College. It is discovered that arsenic added to a bottle of brandy has killed the prelate. Following the murder emerges a scandal in which Dr. Grove is alleged to fornicate with his house servant, Sarah Blundy, who has admitted to the crime.

A few people continued to fight against Cromwell’s tyranny, but only because they thought it right to do so, not because there was any anticipation of success. The number of people sick of despotism increased year by year, but they were too cowed to act without a lead. [Part 2:4]

As the novel plunges into labyrinth of events and findings recalled by each narrator, it is clear that the first three narratives present only a simulacrum of verity. As much as the first account is true, the Venetian physician is not what he appears to be. That he attends to Sarah’s sick mother serves as a disguise that will gain access to the house for some secret papers concerning the state. Jack Prestcott is on a mission to revenge on the death of his father, James Prestcott, a former member of Sealed Knot who has been betrayed. Convinced that John Thurloe (Cromwell’s secretary of state) has hidden the identity of the real traitor at the expense of his father’s fall, Jack pursues Dr. John Wallis, a mathematician who is expertise in decoding cipher, whom he believes is in possession of the coded documents used to incriminate Sir James Prestcott. But Wallis himself lives a life that calls for discretion and he attributes mendacious motives to the Venetian purely out of personal reason.

But these are just mere contour of the truth, which nobody can even fathom.

Of course, the package was that bundle of documents, which Blundy had shown to Sir James Prestcott, and which Thurloe held to be so dangerous he searched for years to recover it. [Part 4:3]

An Instance of the Fingerpost is an intellectual mystery that revolves around the contention between the Commonwealth and the Royalists in 17th century England. Thrown in the plot are grand events of history, the birth of modern science, machinations of politics, interference of religions, and human tragedies. Twists and reversals are the result of countless deeds and decisions, secretly taken and only half known, let alone understood, that slowly accumulate over the years to produce the death of an innocent girl. The many plots and counter-plots, deception and double-dealing are reasons that the book should not be rushed, but savored.

735 pp. Pocket paperback. [Read/Skim/Toss] [Buy/Borrow]

17 Responses

  1. I think this sounds fascinating! I love the concept of not one but four unreliable narrators!

    I am just not sure that I have the intellectual fortitude to actually understand all the plotlines and double meanings to make sense of it all.

    I will definitely add the title to the TBR list when life is less hectic and I can truly devote undivided attention to the complex mystery.

    • Yes, this is exciting book although at times I have to slow down in order to capture all the minute details. Each narrator narrates to his own needs and concern, meaning the account is all somewhat biased. The book takes time and calls for slow reading.

  2. In many ways, it sounds like it is in the same ballpark as Stone’s Fall by Pears. He is long-winded, but he does make it all worthwhile.

    • Oh Sandy, if that’s the case, then I’m going to bump up Stone’s Fall! I think his long-windedness is justified as he gives us lots of details from different angles, some of them extraneous to distract the truth. That makes it all the more intriguing to read. Some of the details are irrelevant of the truth and I realize about halfway through the book that I don’t need to know everything as the whole story is caked with deception.

  3. I’m really looking forward to reading this one. I remember loaning my copy to a work colleague of mine years ago. He had it for about a month, brought it back and layed it on my desk with a stick note that said “good read”. I guess that says it all!

  4. Twists and reversals? This sounds like a lot of fun indeed!

  5. Matt, you’re the only person I know who hasn’t lamented how glacial the pace of this book is or that it took them forever to finish! You are a reading machine! 😀

    • I kept telling my friend whom I have coffee with in the morning (that’s when I read) that An Instance of the Fingerpost is not a casual, easy mystery. Pears gives so many details surrounding the murder and uses the Restoration strife and upheavals as the theater set of the murder. Some of the details, as I read on, are actually extraneous. One might not remember all the details and events that were mentioned in the four narratives and still be able to grasp the truth.

  6. I’ve read this book a long time ago. It’s a great read.


  7. I have been wanting to read something by this author badly. I don’t think I will even know where to start!

    • I couldn’t get into The Dream of Scipio. After that, I stayed away from Iain Pears until blogger Sandy recommended Stone’s Fall, which I plan to read very soon. Then Pears got my attention again and I decided to read An Instance of the Fingerpost before Stone’s Fall.

  8. I’ve had this on my TBR list for ages and couldn’t remember why. Thanks for the reminder!

  9. […] second book I would suggest is completely on the opposite end of the spectrum: An Instance of the Fingerpost by Iain Pears (what a coincidence that they are exactly 200 books apart on my reading journal). A […]

  10. […] order to understand a novel. Three novels on my radar are set in Restoration England. When I read An Instance of the Fingerpost by Iain Pears last year I was totally in the cloud as to why Cromwell had to control England and […]

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: